A mid-century style illustration of a tall black ladder against a teal night sky. The middle rungs are missing, a small figure in an orange jacket stands on the top rung looking down through the gap, and the missing yellow rungs lie in a pile on the ground.

Rush the Title and You Skip the Years That Make You Good

By Derek Neighbors on November 20, 2026

A strong engineer, three years in, gets offered the tech lead role. She gets better work out of the agents than anyone on the team, so the choice looks obvious, and she says yes. Eighteen months later she is setting direction for a system she could not have designed, settling arguments she does not fully understand, and signing off on agent work she would have aimed differently without being able to say why. She can do the work. What the job asks for is judgment she never had time to build, because she was promoted too fast, right out of the years that build it.

I have watched this happen across a lot of engineering teams, and the person almost never blames the promotion. They blame themselves, or the team, or the company. The real cost came earlier, when they traded the cheapest learning years of their career for a title.

If you rush the title, you skip the years that make you good at the job the title describes.

The Myth: You Can’t Get Promoted Too Fast

Ambitious people carry a simple belief. The earlier you get the title, the better your career, so you race to senior and aim to be the youngest director the company has ever had.

It looks true for good reasons. Titles compound. The senior title gets you the bigger offer, the bigger offer gets you the next title, and two years ahead at twenty-eight can mean ten years ahead at forty. Companies reward speed, and so does the market. This year the pressure is stronger, because a junior engineer with Claude in the terminal can ship the pull request count of a senior engineer from five years ago. When the output looks senior, the title feels overdue.

That last part is where the myth fails, because the output showed up years before the judgment that is supposed to come with it.

The Reality Check: The Title Shows Up Before the Judgment

In 1969 Laurence J. Peter and Raymond Hull gave the problem a name. The Peter Principle says people get promoted until they reach a job they cannot do. They wrote the book as satire.

Then economists Alan Benson, Danielle Li, and Kelly Shue tested it on real sales data, and in 2019 they published the results in the Quarterly Journal of Economics. They studied salespeople, because sales output is easy to measure. Firms promoted their best salespeople into management. The best sellers were more likely to get the job, and on average they were worse managers, measured by how their teams performed afterward. The skill that earned the title was not the skill the title needed.

The study only covers sales, so applying it to engineering or design is my own argument. By judgment I mean seeing which facts in a messy situation matter and choosing well when no rule or checklist covers the case. Output can be measured on day one, while judgment shows up only when something goes wrong, which is why a promotion decision built on output keeps missing it.

The same gap shows up across careers. Getting great output from agents earns the lead role, and the lead role needs judging work you did not aim, holding a design in your head that no one person wrote, and telling a peer their approach is wrong without losing them. Closing deals earns the sales manager job, and that job needs coaching someone who closes differently than you do. Getting better at the first skill does nothing for the second, and only reps at the second one build it.

The old craft guilds built this into the path. An apprentice learned the basics under a master. Then came the journeyman years. The word comes from the French journée, a day, because a journeyman was paid by the day and often moved from shop to shop, working under different masters and learning how each one did it. Only after those years did a journeyman submit a masterpiece, the piece of work the guild judged before admitting a new master. The word we now use for someone’s best work started as the test you had to pass before you could run a shop.

The guilds kept that middle stage long, and it was where someone who could do the work became someone who could judge it.

The Hidden Cost: You Spend the Cheapest Margin You Will Ever Have

The fast-track pitch leaves out one thing: the years you skip hold the cheapest margin you will ever have.

By margin I mean the stretch of a career when your mistakes are cheap. You can ship a bad design and the blast radius is one service. You can be the slowest person in the room and nobody’s plan depends on you. Your calendar is mostly yours, and you can spend a whole afternoon pulling apart why a release broke with nothing riding on it except your own curiosity.

The title ends that. Once you lead, your mistakes land on other people. A bad call costs a team a quarter. Your calendar fills with other people’s needs, and the better you get, the faster it fills. I wrote about that squeeze in The Better You Get, the Harder It Is to Focus. You also lose permission to be visibly bad at something. The lead who asks a basic question in a design review pays a price the junior engineer never pays.

You can still buy margin after the title, but it gets expensive, because every hour of learning now costs something someone else needed from you.

The philosopher Gregory Sadler has a series of letters to young philosophers, and one goes to a student tempted to skip the master’s degree on the way to a doctorate. The advice comes down to this: take the time while you still have it. What the student would skip is the slack those years buy, time to read widely and be wrong before being wrong matters. The same advice fits an engineer, a designer, or a salesperson who has a shot at an early promotion.

The Truth: Free Time to Learn Was the Point of the Work

The Greek word for that slack was schole, which means leisure: time free from the work you have to do to survive. The Latin schola comes from it, and so does our word school. School started as the name for what a free person did with their free time.

Aristotle went further. In the Nicomachean Ethics he says we are busy so that we can have leisure, the way we make war so that we can have peace. Leisure, for him, was the point of the work, the time a person used to study, think, and become excellent. A modern career flips that. We treat the early slack as a waiting room and try to get out of it as fast as we can.

The Greek word for what happens in that time is paideia, the formation of a whole person. paideia is the slow shaping of judgment, taste, and character that lets someone handle what no checklist covers. A credential proves you sat in the room, while paideia shows up in what you notice when something goes wrong.

Robert Greene makes the same point in Mastery. The goal of an apprenticeship, he writes, is your own transformation, not money or a title. People who chase the title in those years get the title and keep the old version of themselves. The point of formation is the person you become, and the job is one place that person shows up, with the title as a side effect.

The Shift: Spend the Margin on Reps

Some of this is out of your hands: when an offer comes, what the market pays, whether a manager pushes you into a role. What stays yours is whether you say yes, what you practice while you wait, and how honestly you judge your own readiness. Go as fast as you want on the part that stays yours. Spend the speed on the reps the next title will need, and let the title catch up.

1. Name the skill the next title needs. Write down the job you want next. Then write the one skill it demands that your current job never trains. For the tech lead it might be reading a design you did not write and finding the failure. For a new manager it might be a hard conversation with someone who is not underperforming. Get reps on that skill now, while a bad rep costs you nothing.

2. Use the model to get more reps per year. Margin is limited by the hours you have, and AI changes how many reps fit in an hour. Ask Claude to take your design apart before your lead does. Have it play the frustrated customer, or the engineer who disagrees with your plan, and run the conversation five times. Have it grade your incident write-up against a good one. The model will not grow your judgment for you, but it can pack far more practice into a year than you would get by waiting for work to hand it to you, and that is the best use of a junior’s margin I know.

3. Get into the harder room while being bad is cheap. Join the team where you are the weakest person. It will feel like getting worse, which I covered in Why Getting Better Feels Like Getting Worse. Being the slowest person on a strong team costs you a few rough months at twenty-six and a lot more at forty.

4. Set your own masterpiece test. Decide what you would have to build, run, or fix to prove you are ready for the next title. It might be leading an incident end to end, or shipping a design another team adopts. Take the title when you can pass your own test, and tell your manager the test so they can hold you to it.

5. If you already have the title, buy margin back. You cannot undo a fast promotion, and knowing why you struggle does not excuse it. The people who report to you are paying for the reps you skipped, so closing that gap is your job, and it should happen this year. Margin costs more now, and it is still worth buying. Pick one area each quarter where you are the learner, in public. Ask a junior engineer to show you how they aim agents at a stack you do not know. Sit in on another team’s design review and only ask questions. It costs you something now, which is why most people with the title stop doing it.

Final Thoughts

The early years of a career feel like a line to get through. They are the cheapest years you will get to make mistakes, because nobody needs you to already know the answer. The Greeks called that time schole and treated it as the reason for the work. Run as many reps as you can in those years, use the model to fit more of them in, and take the title when your judgment can carry it. Do it because of who those years turn you into, and the title will take care of itself. Whatever you skip on the way up, you will have to learn later, on someone else’s time and in front of people who are counting on you.

Building judgment goes faster around people who will tell you which rungs you skipped. That is what MasteryLab is for.

FAQ

What does schole mean in Greek?

schole is the ancient Greek word for leisure, meaning time free from necessary work. The Latin schola and the English word school come from it. For Aristotle, leisure was the point of work rather than a break from it, because it was the time a free person used for learning, thinking, and becoming excellent.

What is the Peter Principle?

The Peter Principle, named by Laurence J. Peter and Raymond Hull in 1969, says people in an organization tend to get promoted until they reach a job they cannot do well. A 2019 study by Alan Benson, Danielle Li, and Kelly Shue found the pattern in real sales data: firms promoted their best salespeople into management, and those top sellers were, on average, worse managers.

Should I turn down a promotion if I don’t feel ready?

Not always. Feeling unready is normal and says little. Ask a harder question: which skill does the new role need that your current job has never trained, and have you had real reps on it? If the answer is no, you can take the role and buy those reps fast, or wait a short, defined time and get them first. What you should not do is take the title and assume the judgment will follow on its own.

Practice Excellence Together

Ready to put these principles into practice? Join our Discord community for daily arete audits, peer accountability, and weekly challenges based on the concepts in this article.

Join the Excellence Community