The Power of Conflict: Fuel for Greatness or Sign of Dysfunction?

The Power of Conflict: Fuel for Greatness or Sign of Dysfunction?

By Derek Neighbors on February 20, 2025

Conflict is inevitable in any high-performing team. In fact, it’s necessary. A complete lack of conflict often signals a lack of passion—people simply don’t care enough to push for better outcomes. But too much conflict, if left unresolved, can paralyze an organization.

So how do you distinguish productive conflict from destructive conflict?

Good Conflict vs. Bad Conflict

Good conflict:

Leads to clarity – People challenge each other’s ideas to sharpen thinking and improve outcomes.
Is resolved quickly – Teams process disagreements efficiently, without letting them fester.
Results in action – Conflict serves a purpose: alignment, decision-making, and execution.

Bad conflict:

Becomes personal – Instead of debating ideas, people attack each other.
Stalls execution – No decisions get made, and forward progress stops.
Repeats itself – The same arguments happen over and over, signaling deep misalignment.

Alignment Doesn’t Mean No Conflict

True alignment doesn’t mean everyone always agrees—it means people are committed to resolving disagreements productively. The best teams aren’t free from conflict; they’re skilled at working through it.

A great organization isn’t measured by whether conflict happens. It’s measured by how quickly and effectively it moves through conflict to action.

If your team is constantly fighting and stuck in the same debates, that’s dysfunction. But if there’s never any conflict at all, you might be missing the passion and intensity needed for greatness.

How does your team handle conflict? Are you avoiding it, stuck in it, or using it as a tool for excellence?

Further Reading

Cover of Crucial Conversations

Crucial Conversations

by Kerry Patterson, Joseph Grenny, et al.

Tools for talking when stakes are high and emotions are strong.

Cover of The Five Dysfunctions of a Team

The Five Dysfunctions of a Team

by Patrick Lencioni

A leadership fable about the barriers to effective teamwork and how to overcome them.

Cover of Difficult Conversations

Difficult Conversations

by Douglas Stone, Bruce Patton & Sheila Heen

How to discuss what matters most when stakes are high and emotions are strong.

Cover of Radical Candor

Radical Candor

by Kim Scott

A framework for giving effective feedback and creating a culture of honest communication at work.

Cover of Thanks for the Feedback

Thanks for the Feedback

by Douglas Stone & Sheila Heen

The science and art of receiving feedback well, even when it's off-base, unfair, or poorly delivered.